Clinical Outcome in Children With Culture-Negative Acute Otitis Media.
Leibovitz, Eugene MD *; Nakash, Eyal MD *; Givon-Lavi, Noga PhD *; Greenberg, David MD *; Satran, Robert MD *; Raiz, Semion MD +; Piglansky, Lolita MD *; Leiberman, Alberto MD +; Dagan, Ron MD *
Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal.
28(12):1105-1110, December 2009.
(Format: HTML, PDF)
Background: Culture-negative AOM is often milder and associated with lower local/systemic inflammatory responses than culture-positive AOM.
Study Objectives: To compare the clinical outcome of culture-negative AOM with that of culture-positive AOM children.
Patients and Methods: Children aged 3 to 35 months with AOM were enrolled in 11 double-tympanocentesis antibiotic efficacy studies documenting both bacteriologic (days 4-6 of treatment) and clinical outcome (days 11-14, end of treatment). Univariate analysis (age, gender, ethnicity, previous AOM history, and antibiotic treatment) between culture-negative and culture-positive AOM patients was performed by Student t test, ANOVA, or [chi]2 test. Those found to be significant were further submitted to multivariable regression analysis.
Results: A total of 1088 patients (mean age, 11.95 /- 5.96 months, 209 culture-negative and 879 culture-positive AOM) were enrolled. No differences were recorded between culture-negative AOM and culture-positive AOM patients in age, gender, ethnicity and number of previous episodes. Seventy-four percent (650/879) culture-positive AOM patients achieved bacteriologic eradication within 3 to 5 days. Successful outcome (cured improved) was recorded in 90% (189/209) culture-negative AOM patients versus 86% (758/879) in culture-positive AOM (P = 0.086). Successful clinical outcome was more frequent in culture-negative than in culture-positive AOM without bacteriologic eradication (90% vs. 67% [154/229], P < 0.001). No difference in successful clinical outcome was found between culture-negative versus culture-positive AOM patients with bacterial eradication (90% vs. 93% [604/650], P = 0.24). Overall, the inclusion of culture-negative AOM patients in the evaluation of clinical failures rates in study patients decreased the total clinical failure rate by 9%. We present a hypothetical antibiotic efficacy study enrolling 300 patients in whom 2 drugs with different bacteriologic efficacy rates (A-90% and B-60%) were used. When the culture-negative cases (5% clinical failure) enrolled increased from 50/300 (16.7%) to 150/300 (50%), the overall clinical failure rate decreased by 36% (from 17.4% to 11.2%, P = 0.08) for the less efficacious drug, while remaining unmodified for the more efficacious drug (9.6% and 8.8%, respectively).
Conclusions: (1) Clinical outcome in culture-negative AOM was similar to that of culture-positive AOM with bacteriologic eradication and both were superior to that of culture-positive AOM without eradication; (2) Inclusion of culture-negative AOM patients in series aiming at antibiotic efficacy may falsely improve the clinical outcome for antibiotics with reduced ability to eradicate AOM pathogens.
(C) 2009 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.