Efficacy of 2 Non-Weight-Bearing Interventions, Proprioception Training Versus Strength Training, for Patients With Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Clinical Trial.
LIN, DA-HON MD 1; LIN, CHIEN-HO JANICE RPT, PhD 2; LIN, YEONG-FWU MD, PhD 3; JAN, MEI-HWA RPT, MS 4
Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy.
39(6):450-457, June 2009.
(Format: HTML, PDF)
STUDY DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the clinical and functional efficacy of 2 different non-weightbearing exercise regimens, proprioceptive training (PrT) versus strength training (ST), for patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA).
BACKGROUND: Both strength and proprioceptive training are important interventions for individuals with knee OA. The benefits of weightbearing exercises are generally recognized in the clinical setting. However, exercising in a standing or weight-bearing position may aggravate symptoms in patients with knee OA.
METHODS AND MEASURES: One hundred eight patients were randomly assigned to the PrT, ST, or no exercise (control) group for an 8-week intervention. Both the PrT and ST interventions consisted of non-weight-bearing exercises. Western Ontario and MacMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index-pain (WOMAC-pain) and -function scores, walking time on 3 different terrains, knee strength, and absolute knee reposition error were assessed before and after intervention. Data were analyzed using mixed-model ANOVAs.
RESULTS: Both PrT and ST significantly improved WOMAC-pain and -function score after intervention (P<.008). The improvement secondary to ST in the WOMAC-function scores (17.2 points) and for knee extension strength (10.3-14.9 Nm) was greater than the minimally clinically important difference for these measurements. The PrT group demonstrated greater improvement in walking time on a spongy surface and knee reposition error than the other 2 groups. No improvements were apparent in the control group.
CONCLUSION: Both types of non-weightbearing exercises (PrT and ST) significantly improved outcomes in this study. PrT led to greater improvements in proprioceptive function, while ST resulted in a greater increase in knee extensor muscle strength.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapy, level 1b.
(C) Copyright 2009 Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy